Case Study

Tank Shell & Roof FEA Verification — Wind & Seismic Load Analysis

FEA Analysis — Storage TankConfidential Details Removed
Request Similar Engineering Support WhatsApp

SLETEC portfolio

Project Images & Evidence — API 650 Roof Access, Hydrostatic & Safety Verification

Selected engineering evidence from SLETEC projects. Client names and identifiers are withheld for confidentiality.

High-SG Hydrostatic Verification1.83 SG fluid, pressure gradient, shell stress and deformation checks at 4,450 mm fill height.
Roof Safety & Access ArrangementScaffold, fall-protection and tank-roof interface for access through a roof manhole.
Load Path & Reaction ReviewGravity, wind and concentrated reactions around roof openings, with support reaction check.
High-SG Hydrostatic & Shell Verification1.83 SG liquid loading, shell stress, deformation and repair verification.
Tank Roof & Shell FEATotal deformation, stress, buckling and serviceability evidence for roof stiffness and maximum displacement.

Scope

Roof access, temporary works, anchors, hydrostatic shell checks

Codes

API 650 · AISC 360 · project criteria

Deliverables

Verification reports with reactions and acceptance checks

Case study · Ref. 79 · STORAGE TANK

High-SG Liquid in an Existing Tank

Challenge: Confirm the safe filling height when an existing Ø6,096 mm, 5.3 mm-shell vertical tank stores a 1.83 SG fluid.

Approach: Static-structural FEA of the shell under hydrostatic pressure gradient, with deformation and stress review against the target stress level.

Outcome: Filling height of 4,450 mm established at a maximum shell stress of 48.02 MPa — a clear operating limit for the owner.

Case study · Ref. 77 · ACCESS SAFETY

Scaffold Access Through a Tank Roof

Challenge: Verify a scaffold arrangement entering through a roof manhole without overloading the dome roof.

Approach: FEA of roof and scaffold interface under gravity, wind and scaffold reactions; global equilibrium and reaction checks.

Outcome: Max vertical deformation +0.51 mm with total support reaction ≈ 4.90 × 10⁴ N — access approved within serviceability limits.

Problem / Requirement

A large-diameter floating-roof tank required verification beyond the prescriptive API 650 shell thickness formula because the diameter-to-height ratio fell outside standard applicability limits. The client's third-party inspector requested an FEA-backed report confirming the shell would not buckle under design wind speed and that the floating roof pontoon remained structurally adequate under combined hydrostatic and seismic sloshing loads.

Engineering Scope

Development of a detailed axisymmetric and 3-D FEA shell model from fabrication drawings
Application of hydrostatic pressure, wind pressure profile per ASCE 7 and internal vacuum loading cases
Linear buckling (eigenvalue) analysis to determine critical wind speed and safety factor against shell buckling
Non-linear post-buckling analysis to confirm load redistribution behaviour under extreme wind
Seismic sloshing load derivation per API 650 Annex E and application to floating roof pontoon
Stress linearisation across pontoon deck, rim plate and drainage system connection nodes
Weld joint stress and fatigue screening at critical pontoon-to-deck intersections
Preparation of FEA report with acceptance criteria, contour plots and pass/fail summary

Deliverables

FEA Model Description and Validation Report Shell Buckling Analysis Report — Wind Load Floating Roof Pontoon Stress Analysis Report Seismic Sloshing Load Calculation Sheet FEA Contour Plot Pack (Stress, Displacement, Buckling Modes) Acceptance Criteria Compliance Summary Table

Client Value Delivered

FEA confirmed shell integrity at 160 km/h design wind, giving the client confidence ahead of the third-party audit
Buckling safety factor of 3.2 demonstrated — no stiffener rings required, saving material and fabrication cost
Floating roof pontoon stress results were below yield at all load combinations, avoiding costly redesign
Structured report with explicit acceptance criteria cross-references satisfied the inspector's requirements on first submission
Sloshing freeboard check confirmed existing tank height was adequate, eliminating the need for raised pontoon guides

Standards Referenced

API 650 (12th Ed.) API 650 Annex E API 650 Annex F ASCE 7-22 ASME BPVC Sec. VIII Div. 2 (stress limits) EN 1993-1-6 (shell buckling guidance)

Software Used

ANSYS Mechanical 2024 R1 ANSYS Workbench TANK (Intergraph) — baseline check Microsoft Excel (load derivation) AutoCAD 2024 (geometry reference)

Need Similar Engineering?

Contact SLETEC to discuss your project scope and receive a tailored proposal.

Request Support

Frequently asked questions

What safe filling height did SLETEC establish for the high-SG tank?
4,450 mm for a 1.83 SG fluid in an existing Ø6,096 mm tank with a 5.3 mm shell, at a maximum shell stress of 48.02 MPa.
Was scaffold access through the roof approved?
Yes. FEA gave a maximum vertical deformation of +0.51 mm and a total support reaction of about 4.90 × 10⁴ N, within serviceability limits.
Why use FEA instead of code formulas?
Because the loading — a heavier product and scaffold loads on the roof — is outside the standard API 650 design cases.

Last updated: