Engineering guide
Lifting Lug Design to ASME BTH-1: What Engineers Need to Check
Lifting lug design is the process of sizing a lug plate, its pin hole, its welds and the structure it is attached to so that a load can be lifted safely under every sling angle and load case in the lift plan. This guide explains how ASME BTH-1 is applied to lugs, the inputs needed, the checks that govern and the mistakes we see most often when reviewing lug calculations.
Last updated:
Where ASME BTH-1 applies to lugs
ASME BTH-1, Design of Below-the-Hook Lifting Devices, covers devices such as spreader beams, lifting frames and plate clamps that sit between the crane hook and the load. Strictly, a lug welded permanently to a vessel, skid or module is part of the load rather than a below-the-hook device, so it is not always within the formal scope of the standard.
In practice BTH-1 is widely used for lug design because its rules for pin-connected plates are clear, conservative and well understood by reviewers. Many owner specifications require it explicitly. Where the project specification names a different basis, such as a regional lifting standard or an offshore rule set with its own dynamic and consequence factors, that basis governs and should be stated in the calculation.
Design category and service class
BTH-1 asks the designer to select a design category, which sets the design factor applied to the allowable stresses. Design Category A uses a lower design factor and is intended for lifts where the magnitude and variation of loads are predictable and dynamic effects are small. Design Category B uses a higher design factor and is intended where loads are less predictable or the consequences of failure are more serious.
For equipment lugs used on construction lifts, Design Category B is a common and sensible default unless the project specification says otherwise. The standard also defines service classes based on the expected number of load cycles; most equipment lugs see few lifts in their life and fall into the lowest service class, where fatigue does not need to be checked. Lugs on frequently lifted items such as containers or test weights may need a higher class.
Whatever category is chosen, it should be stated on the lug drawing as well as in the calculation, so that anyone reusing the lug later knows the basis it was designed to.
Inputs you need before sizing a lug
A lug calculation should start from the lift plan, not from a standard lug drawing. The same lug can be adequate for a vertical lift and inadequate for an angled lift with an unequal load share.
Where the rigging includes a spreader beam or lifting frame, the sling angles at the lugs depend on that device's geometry, so the lug and rigging calculations should be prepared together and use the same assumptions.
| Input | Notes |
|---|---|
| Lifted weight and centre of gravity | Include contingency for weight uncertainty as the project requires |
| Number of lugs and rigging arrangement | Determines load share; statically indeterminate rigging needs care |
| Sling angles in plan and elevation | Gives in-plane and out-of-plane components on each lug |
| Dynamic or impact factor | Set by the lift plan, project specification or governing standard |
| Shackle size and type | Fixes pin diameter, jaw width and the required hole and plate dimensions |
| Lug and parent material grades | Yield and tensile strength, thickness and toughness |
| Parent component geometry | Shell thickness, stiffeners or beam section at the attachment |
The checks that govern a pin-connected lug
BTH-1 treats a lug as a pin-connected plate and requires several independent strength checks around the hole, plus checks on the rest of the load path. The pin-hole checks use an effective width that is limited by the plate thickness and hole diameter, so simply making a lug wider does not always increase its capacity.
The standard also sets proportioning rules for the hole and plate. The clearance between pin and hole affects the bearing stress distribution, which is one reason the shackle pin and hole should be matched rather than chosen independently.
- Tensile strength through the pin hole
- Double-plane shear beyond the pin hole
- Bearing of the pin on the plate, including any cheek plates
- Dishing or out-of-plane stability for thin plates where applicable
- Combined tension, bending and shear at the lug base from in-plane and out-of-plane components
- Weld strength at the lug-to-parent connection for the combined loads
- Local stress in the parent shell or member at the attachment
Welds and the parent structure
Lug failures often start not in the lug itself but at the weld or in the parent material. Fillet welds are acceptable for many lugs, but where the lug sees significant bending or out-of-plane load, a full-penetration weld with suitable inspection is often specified. The weld check must use the same combined load components as the lug base, not just the vertical sling force.
On pressure vessels and tanks the shell local stress at the lug pad usually needs its own check. Methods based on WRC bulletins can be used for simple cases, while lugs near discontinuities, on thin shells or with large out-of-plane components are better assessed with finite-element analysis. Our guide comparing WRC 537 and FEA for local loads covers the same choice for nozzles. Vessels lifted from horizontal to vertical need tailing lugs and trunnions checked through the full rotation, because the load direction changes throughout the upend.
Common mistakes in lug calculations
Most of these are visible on a single page of the calculation. A reviewer should be able to see the lifted weight, the load per lug with its components, the governing check and its utilisation without searching.
- Checking only the vertical load and ignoring the out-of-plane component from sling angle
- Assuming equal load share with four slings on a rigid load, when two diagonally opposite lugs may carry most of it
- Choosing the hole size without checking that the specified shackle pin and jaw width actually fit
- Omitting the parent shell or beam check, or using nominal instead of corroded thickness on existing equipment
- Applying the dynamic factor twice, once in the lift plan and again in the design factor, or not at all
- No traceable reference to the design category or governing code in the calculation
When to get an engineer involved
Simple lugs for light vertical lifts are often designed in-house using a validated template. An engineer should be involved for heavy or critical lifts, tandem lifts, upending of vessels, lugs on thin shells or existing equipment, and any lift where the rigging is statically indeterminate. Proof-load testing and non-destructive examination requirements should also be set by an engineer in line with the project specification.
SLETEC prepares lug and trunnion calculations, rigging checks and fabrication details for equipment lifts. For the service itself see our lifting lug calculation page, and for wider rigging studies our lifting and rigging calculations service.
Frequently asked questions
Is a welded lifting lug covered by ASME BTH-1?
A lug permanently welded to the load is not strictly a below-the-hook lifting device, so it can fall outside the formal scope of BTH-1. Its pin-connected plate rules are nevertheless widely used for lug design, and many project specifications require them. The calculation should state the basis clearly.
Should I use Design Category A or B?
Design Category B uses a higher design factor and suits lifts where loads are less predictable or failure consequences are serious. It is a common default for equipment lugs on construction lifts. Use Category A only where the project specification permits it and the lift conditions justify it.
Does a lifting lug need a full-penetration weld?
Not always. Fillet welds are adequate for many lugs, but significant bending or out-of-plane loading often makes a full-penetration weld the better choice. The weld must be checked for the combined load components at the lug base.
Why do sling angles matter so much?
A sling at an angle increases the force in the sling and adds horizontal components at the lug. If the lug is not aligned with the sling, part of that force acts out of the lug plane, where the plate is weak in bending. Ignoring this is one of the most common causes of lug calculation errors.
Discuss your project with an engineer
Send drawings, datasheets or a short scope – an engineer replies with scope, schedule and price, usually within 24 hours.